|
What
is the explanation of suffering?
|
HINDUISM |
Karma and Maya: we always reap
what we sow, and the suffering we receive is always what we deserve for
or misdeeds in this or in previous incarnations; may (illusions) cause
us to feel confused, unhappy; Maya leads us to do things which bring us
our bad karma. |
|
BUDDHISM: HINAYANA |
Karma, desire, and the
illusion of Self; we reap what we sow; the illusion of self causes us to
desire things; when we are disappointed we suffer; when we try to meet
our desires, we create bad karma which brings suffering. |
|
BUDDHISM: MAHAYANA |
The same as Hinayana Buddhism. |
|
TAOISM |
Our going against the Tao,
forcing our will upon nature so that nature must "strike back"
to restore its equilibrium. |
|
CONFUCIANISM |
Our lack of wisdom; our
failure to follow the ways of the ancients so that our relationships
become painful and frustrating. |
|
JUDAISM |
When human beings rebel
against the will of YHWH, they bring disaster upon themselves.
Originally, the emphasis if Judaism was that suffering was a sign
that God was punishing and individual for his sinfulness. As the faith
developed, it came to be more and more emphasized that human beings are
tied into larger units of family, clan, nation and humanity; and
that one person's sin may lead not to his suffering, but to
others' sorrow. |
|
ISLAM |
Much the same as Judaism,
with, perhaps, more emphasis on the inscrutable will of Allah. Whatever
happens in this world has been decreed by Allah; one doesn't so much
seek an explanation for suffering as simply accept it and submit to the
will of Allah. |
|
CHRISTIANITY: ORTHODOX |
Much like Judaism, but with a
difference: the New Testament hints at the idea that God is still in the
act of creation and that the natural universe is itself still
"incomplete": the natural world of floods, earthquakes, et,
can be a dangerous place. Like the Jews, too, Christians stress the
inter-relatedness of life: one man's genius may enrich many lifes; one
man's selfishness may mar many lifes. But Christianity, more than
Judaism -- although this idea is found also in Judaism -- believes that
suffering can be transformed by God's love into a blessing: out of evil,
God can create good if his people will trust Him with their pain.
Without danger, we could never be brave; without suffering, we could
never be compassionate; and so forth. The supreme example is the
crucifixion of Jesus: by any measure, it was a tragedy, a miscarriage of
justice an agonizing death, the failure of a good man; but out of the
cross came "resurrection" and the cross, itself, has become a
symbol of love and mercy and unending forgiveness. |
|
CHRISTIANITY: ROMAN CATHOLIC |
Same |
|
CHRISTIANITY: PROTESTANTISM |
Same |
Return
|